• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Main Navigation
  • Skip to Search

IUPUI IUPUI IUPUI

Open Search Menu

Lilly Family School of Philanthropy

  • Home
  • About
    • Founding of the School
    • History
    • Message from the Dean
    • International
    • Dean’s Newsletter
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Partnerships
    • Annual Reports
    • Strategic Plan
    • University Hall
  • Admissions
    • How to Apply
    • Financial Aid & Scholarships
    • Student Referrals
    • Plan a Visit
  • Academics
    • B.A. in Philanthropic Studies
    • M.A. in Philanthropic Studies
    • Graduate Certificate in Philanthropic Studies
    • Ph.D. in Philanthropic Studies
    • Dual Degree Programs
    • Certificates & Minors
    • Accelerated B.A./M.A. Program
    • Internships
    • Careers
    • Meet our Faculty
    • Philanthropic Studies Library
    • Study Abroad
    • Alumni and Student Map
  • Professional Development
    • About The Fund Raising School
    • Courses & Seminars
    • Customized Training
    • Certificates
    • Scholarships
    • Mobile App
    • Webinars
    • Podcast
    • News You Can Use
  • Research
    • Current Research Projects
    • Contract Research
    • Generosity for Life
    • Global Philanthropy Indices
    • Million Dollar List
    • Partnerships
    • Faculty Research & Publications
    • Lilly Family Faculty & Student Grants
    • Research Archive
  • Institutes
    • Lake Institute on Faith & Giving
    • Mays Family Institute on Diverse Philanthropy
    • Women’s Philanthropy Institute
  • News & Events
    • Blog
    • News
    • Events
    • Philanthropy Matters
    • Insights Newsletter
    • Alumni Connection Newsletter
    • Philanthropy Research Workshop
  • Giving
    • Make a Gift
    • Areas to Support
    • Giving Societies
    • Class Gift
    • Donor Bill of Rights
    • Bicentennial Campaign
  • Search
  • Directory
  • Contact
  • Alumni
  • Blog
  • News
  • Events
  • Philanthropy Matters
  • Insights Newsletter
    • 2019 Issues
    • 2018 Issues
    • 2017 Issues
    • 2016 Issues
  • Alumni Connection Newsletter
  • Philanthropy Research Workshop
  • Home
  • News & Events
  • Insights Newsletter
  • 2017 Issues
  • Why Give?

Why Give?

Tuesday, February 14, 2017

David King: Lake Institute on Faith & Giving
David P. King, Ph.D.

Faith traditions inspire different donor motivations as the past still inspires the present

Why do people give? It is a good question and one that scholars of philanthropy have been eager to study. When reviewing the literature, Professors René Bekkers and Paula Wiepking boiled donors’ motivations down to eight reasons people give to charity:

  1. Awareness of Need
  2. Being asked
  3. Benefits – special services (e.g. box seats to their university’s football game)
  4. Altruism
  5. Reputation – approval from others (e.g. having your named listed among donors in the program)
  6. Psychological Benefits – experiencing the joy of giving
  7. Values – your own values align with the mission of an institution
  8. Efficacy - The perception that a gift makes a difference in the cause the donor believes in.

While these motivations are undoubtedly true, I don’t think they capture the full picture. They also demonstrate that much of the scholarship has been done by sociologists, psychologists, and economists. If we stepped back and set the impulse of giving within various religious traditions, would we see other motivations rise to the fore?

In a past edition of Insights, we looked at the debates over the terms charity and philanthropy. In setting itself up in contrast to charity, professional philanthropy has often sought to situate its strategic and systematic approach as superior to individual and haphazard charity. As we argued in that piece, however, the terms then and now have often been much more intertwined. When we attend to religious cultures, we see that sacred texts and traditions are alive. Literary scholars talk about reception history – how a text has been received and reinterpreted throughout time. So traditions of religious giving are neither remnants of the distant past, or frozen in time, incapable of change. And they are also essential motivating factors for many religious individuals. While not popular techniques for fundraisers, motivations like duty, obligation, and sacrifice remain powerful factors. Other ancient motivators such as justice, building community, and repairing the world have a much more modern flavor.

Therefore, despite the distance between the founding of many of major religious traditions and the present, the sway these traditions hold over individual givers, in the way in which they describe why and how they give, cannot be dismissed. Re-envisioned and reinterpreted to be sure, but rarely dismissed entirely. While that may be the case, still too often, we write off our histories that have shaped our various philanthropic traditions. In this context, it is a bit odd that we have found a mini-revival of interest in economic histories of charity, almsgiving in the early Judeo-Christian world. In 2013, University of Notre Dame scholar Gary Anderson published the well-received Charity: The Place of the Poor in the Biblical Tradition. Princeton historian emeritus Peter Brown has written no less than three book on wealth in early Christianity, his latest Treasure in Heaven: the Holy Poor in Early Christianity, released in 2016. Even more recently, Fuller Theological Seminary professor David J. Downs published Alms: Charity, Reward, and Atonement in Early Christianity, in which he meticulously examines biblical and intertestamental texts and their reception by early Jewish and Christian teachers.

What these scholars find are some motivations to give that feel quite familiar to the teachings of Abrahamic religious traditions. But at other times, the reasons to give might look quite foreign. While all point to the same evidence, Downs in particular highlights the language of atonement for Jewish and early Christian almsgiving.

Brown notes that Christians offered alms on earth in order to “store up treasures in heaven” – meriting future rewards as motivations for giving. Downs walks readers through multiple texts, and their reception by the early Christian fathers, which highlight almsgiving as atoning for sin (often interpreted by Downs as more social, communal failings over individual faults).

“Give alms from your possessions. Do not turn your face away from any of the poor, so that God’s face will not be turned away from you. Give in proportion to what you own. If you have great wealth, give alms out of your abundance; if you have but little, do not be afraid to give alms even of that little. You will be storing up a goodly treasure for yourself against the day of adversity. For almsgiving delivers from death and keeps one from entering into Darkness. Almsgiving is a worthy offering in the sight of the Most High for all who practice it.” Tobit 4:7-11

In some ways, these ancient texts feel removed from our current contexts, and certainly most of us find ourselves relying on multiple motives, cultures, and traditions when we give – whether consciously or not. Yet, at the same time, that also means that these ancient giving traditions are worthy of studying. Far from dead, these are living theologies and religious practices that the majority of the global population engages in some way. Quite often these theologies of charity not only scripted giving practices, but charity also defined the identity of religious communities from one another and others. This was particularly true in their insistence on the care for the poor, outcast, and refugee. Unfortunately, these issues of justice are far from ancient history. Let us remember, though, that neither are the multitude of motivations that encourage the charity/philanthropy of millions of religious individuals.

Women's Philanthropy Institute Symposium

Women have a long history in American philanthropy and civil society.  What’s different today is that women have more access to wealth than ever before – some say as much as $13.2 trillion in North America alone – and their voices, perspectives, leadership, and resources are shaping philanthropy in bold, innovative ways.  The Women’s Philanthropy Institute (WPI) will explore this intersection of women, philanthropy, and civil society at its 2017 symposium, DREAM DARE DO, March 14-15 in Chicago. 

Unique among philanthropy conferences, the triennial WPI symposium: (1) focuses on the “why” and “how” rather than the how-to; (2) provides an opportunity for attendees to step back from day-to-day demands and reflect on trends, developments, and the future of women’s philanthropy; (3) convenes under a “big tent,” i.e., women leaders from across the women’s philanthropy spectrum and the for profit sector for thoughtful conversation and deliberation; and (4) examines the myriad ways in which women act in civil society for the common good.

With 27 remarkable speakers who will inspire you with their powerful stories, DREAM DARE DO asks attendees to think critically about finding solutions in the 21st century.  Registration is limited to ensure opportunity for discussion and networking.  Register online today.

Learn more and register
DREAM. DARE. DO. Symposium: Women's Philanthropy Institute

Alms: Charity, Reward, and Atonement in Early Christianity

If you want to learn more about the role that atonement plays in the language of charity in the Christian tradition, as highlighted in Dr. King's reflection above, check out this seminal book by Dr. David J. Downs of Fuller Theological Seminary.

Purchase book
Alms book

Lilly Family School of Philanthropy social media channels

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

Fulfilling the Promise

Indiana University

Copyright © 2019 The Trustees of Indiana University

Accessibility | Privacy Notice

  • About
    • Founding of the School
    • History
    • Message from the Dean
    • International
    • Dean’s Newsletter
      • 2019 Issues
      • 2018 Issues
      • 2017 Issues
      • 2016 Issues
      • 2015 Issues
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Partnerships
    • Annual Reports
    • Strategic Plan
    • University Hall
  • Admissions
    • How to Apply
      • B.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • M.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • Graduate Certificate in Philanthropic Studies
      • Ph.D. in Philanthropic Studies
    • Financial Aid & Scholarships
      • B.A. Scholarships
      • M.A. Scholarships
      • Executive Master's Scholarships
      • Doctoral Dissertation Fellowships
        • Women's Philanthropy Institute Doctoral Dissertation Fellowship
      • AmeriCorps Alums
    • Student Referrals
    • Plan a Visit
  • Academics
    • B.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • B.A. Student Profiles
      • Celebrity Philanthropy course
    • M.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • Enrollment and Placement Data
      • M.A. Program Testimonials
    • Graduate Certificate in Philanthropic Studies
    • Ph.D. in Philanthropic Studies
      • Doctoral Minor in Philanthropic Studies
      • Enrollment and Placement Data
    • Dual Degree Programs
    • Certificates & Minors
    • Accelerated B.A./M.A. Program
    • Internships
    • Careers
      • Career & Leadership Preparedness
    • Meet our Faculty
    • Philanthropic Studies Library
    • Study Abroad
    • Alumni and Student Map
  • Professional Development
    • About The Fund Raising School
      • Our Faculty
      • Alumni Stories
    • Courses & Seminars
      • Course Locations
      • Offered by The Fund Raising School
      • Leadership Roundtable
      • How to Register
    • Customized Training
      • Fundraising for Deans
    • Certificates
      • Fund Raising Management
      • Fund Raising Leadership
      • Nonprofit Executive Leadership
      • Accreditation
    • Scholarships
      • Dottie Rosso Scholarship
      • Hank Rosso Scholarship
    • Mobile App
    • Webinars
      • Archive
    • Podcast
    • News You Can Use
  • Research
    • Current Research Projects
    • Contract Research
    • Generosity for Life
    • Global Philanthropy Indices
    • Million Dollar List
    • Partnerships
    • Faculty Research & Publications
      • Books
    • Lilly Family Faculty & Student Grants
    • Research Archive
  • Institutes
    • Lake Institute on Faith & Giving
      • Courses & Seminars
        • Cultivating Generous Congregations
        • Executive Certificate in Religious Fundraising
      • Annual Programs
      • Grants & Scholarships
      • Recommended Faith & Giving Resources
      • Board of Advisors
      • Muslim Philanthropy Initiative
    • Mays Family Institute on Diverse Philanthropy
      • About
      • Events
      • Resources
    • Women’s Philanthropy Institute
      • Research
      • Newest Report
      • History & Resources
      • Council
      • Complete Research Library
        • Infographics & Visuals
  • News & Events
    • Blog
    • News
    • Events
    • Philanthropy Matters
      • 2019 Issues
      • 2018 Issues
      • 2017 Issues
      • 2016 Issues
      • 2015 Issues
    • Insights Newsletter
      • 2019 Issues
      • 2018 Issues
      • 2017 Issues
      • 2016 Issues
    • Alumni Connection Newsletter
      • 2018 Issues
      • 2017 Issues
    • Philanthropy Research Workshop
      • Spring 2018
      • Fall 2017
      • Spring 2017
      • Fall 2016
  • Giving
    • Make a Gift
    • Areas to Support
    • Giving Societies
    • Class Gift
    • Donor Bill of Rights
    • Bicentennial Campaign
      • Initiatives and Partnerships
      • Convening Intellectual Leaders
      • Seeding Research
      • Training the Next Generation
  • Directory
  • Contact
  • Alumni
    • Alumni Board
    • Contact Info
    • Distinguished Alumni
    • Get Involved
    • Share Your Success