• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Main Navigation
  • Skip to Search

IUPUI IUPUI IUPUI

Open Search Menu

Lilly Family School of Philanthropy

  • Home
  • About
    • Founding of the School
    • History
    • Message from the Dean
    • International
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Partnerships
    • Annual Reports
    • Strategic Plan
    • University Hall
  • Admissions
    • How to Apply
    • Financial Aid & Scholarships
    • Student Referrals
    • Plan a Visit
  • Academics
    • B.A. in Philanthropic Studies
    • M.A. in Philanthropic Studies
    • Graduate Certificates
    • Ph.D. in Philanthropic Studies
    • Dual Degree Programs
    • Certificates & Minors
    • Accelerated B.A./M.A. Program
    • Virtual Commencement 2020
    • Internships
    • Careers
    • Meet our Faculty
    • Philanthropic Studies Library
    • Study Abroad
    • Alumni and Student Map
  • Professional Development
    • About The Fund Raising School
    • TFRS at Your Desk
    • Courses & Seminars
    • Customized Training
    • Certificates
    • Scholarships
    • Mobile App
    • Webinars
    • Podcast
  • Research
    • COVID-19 Tracking
    • Current Research Projects
    • Contract Research
    • 8 Myths of Philanthropy
    • Generosity for Life
    • Global Philanthropy Indices
    • Million Dollar List
    • Partnerships
    • Faculty Research & Publications
    • Lilly Family Faculty & Student Grants
    • Research Archive
  • Institutes
    • Lake Institute on Faith & Giving
    • Mays Family Institute on Diverse Philanthropy
    • Women’s Philanthropy Institute
  • News & Events
    • Philanthropy and COVID-19
    • News
    • Blog
    • Events
    • Philanthropy Matters
    • Insights Newsletter
    • Philanthropy Research Workshop
  • Giving
    • Make a Gift
    • Areas to Support
    • Giving Societies
    • Class Gift
    • Donor Bill of Rights
  • Search
  • Directory
  • Contact
  • Alumni
  • Philanthropy and COVID-19
  • News
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Philanthropy Matters
  • Insights Newsletter
    • 2021 Issues
    • 2020 Issues
    • 2019 Issues
    • 2018 Issues
    • 2017 Issues
    • 2016 Issues
  • Philanthropy Research Workshop
  • Home
  • News & Events
  • Insights Newsletter
  • 2018 Issues
  • Is Stewardship Ethical?

Is Stewardship Ethical?

Tuesday, May 22, 2018

David King: Lake Institute on Faith & Giving

by Dr. David P. King, Karen Lake Buttrey Director

Stewardship, generosity and abundance can be beautiful metaphors that often lead us to avoid talking about money. Although it may be possible to fundraise within congregations while mentioning money as little as possible, the cost may be a domesticated theology of stewardship. Avoiding money-talk deprives faith traditions of some of their greatest assets in confronting issues of justice in our world where business practices, questions of privilege, and social ethics are completely wrapped up in economic issues. And if we don’t want to talk about money personally, it is rarely any easier to address these pressing issues more broadly in our society.

This is what Reinhold Niebuhr saw in 1930 when he wrote a piece for the Christian Century entitled, “Is Stewardship Ethical?” As the story goes, the young Niebuhr had made a name for himself as a Lutheran pastor who had just taken a post at Union Theological Seminary deeply engaged in social issues: pacifism, labor, and economic challenges. Faced with a deadline for submitting his regular Christian Century piece, Niebuhr decided to write on stewardship ethics: “did the churches have anything important to say about the ethical character of the entire western civilization?”[1]

In examining the question, Niebuhr shined a light on how the church talked or didn’t talk about money. It’s easy for us to think that stewardship has just always been, but at least in the American church, what counts as “traditional” stewardship practices today are a relatively new innovation. Only toward the end of the 19th century did denominations begin to make the case for Christians to tithe to the church out of a sense of duty and commitment. And the language of stewardship only gained popularity between the world wars. Like today, American society was undergoing drastic changes: widespread urbanization, immigration, and increasing tribalism. To sustain the growth of American congregations in the midst of these great transitions, denominations developed a language of stewardship. At the same time, the practice of stewardship often seemed siloed from the pressing issues of the day. And so Niebuhr asked, “Is this stewardship ethical?”

Niebuhr was skeptical that conventional stewardship language could speak to current moral complexities. He called out the church as too easily satisfied – too quick to praise the virtue of the philanthropic gifts made by those with concentrated wealth and power. He claimed that “the apparently voluntary nature of a gift does not necessarily make it a truly ethical act.” We have avoided the ethical question. How did “your man of power and privilege,” Niebuhr would ask, “make his money?” How does he treat his workers? This too is a stewardship question and required what Niebuhr called a depth and range of ethical imagination. Of course, as a Christian realist, Niebuhr admitted that Protestant teachings on giving are full of mixed motives, but he challenged the Protestant churches to see stewardship as an ethical issue – personal, communal, global.[2]

Yet the churches largely ignored him. Niebuhr went on to become the most recognizable public theologian of the 20th century, and stewardship principles and techniques went on just as they had before. Scholars in their ivory towers and grass-roots advocates on the ground fought for labor, tax reform, civil rights, but neither saw this as the work of stewardship. At the same time, churches entered the most prosperous period of post-World War II institutional building and public prestige, but they rarely saw their fundraising campaigns as an ethical issue.

By the 1970s, in response to a new set of moral crises and increasing affluence, a renewed theological ethic of stewardship emerged. Renowned Christian social ethicist Max Stackhouse again pointed to the temptation to see stewardship as the menial task of raising the budget: “In our reactions against seeing stewardship only as fund-raising, we must not be tempted to ignore the reality of economics and money… Stewardship is the Christian way of speaking of responsible economics.”[3] And the 1970s – like the 1930s in the midst of the Great Depression – was an interesting test-case. There was the end of Vietnam, the resignation of a sitting President, the growth of corporations yet the financial pinch of an ongoing energy crisis.

Stackhouse also went on to propose a “stewardship ethic” for the church, and like Niebuhr, stewardship ministries have largely ignored it – following the same principles and techniques to raise budgets, fulfill capital campaigns, and support the work of the church.[4] Perhaps, today we’re in a similar time – where the issues of our day are leading us to consider the full scope of our theology and practice of stewardship. Like Niebuhr and the Great Depression, Stackhouse in the midst of an unpopular war and a global energy crisis, we face our own challenges: an unprecedented refugee crisis in Syria, civil war in Yemen, mass starvation in South Sudan, Somalia, Nigeria. And even closer to home, we are reflecting on Ferguson, Charlottesville, not to mention debates over health care and tax reform. Unlike the response of the majority of congregations over past decades, we may no longer have the luxury of ignoring theologians’ critiques and we may no longer be able to simply go about stewardship business as usual.

Is Stewardship ethical? A strange question, but maybe one worth considering.


[1] Reinhold Niebuhr, “Is Stewardship Ethical?” Christian Century 47 (April 30, 1930): 555-557.

[2] Niebuhr, “Is Stewardship Ethical?” 555-557.

[3] Max Stackhouse, “Toward a Stewardship Ethics,” in Teaching and Preaching Stewardship: An Anthology, edited by Nordan C. Murphy, pp. 87-111. Library of Christian Stewardship. New York: Commission on Stewardship, National Council of the Churches of Christ in the U.S.A, 1985.

[4] Max Stackhouse, Public Theology and Political Economy: Christian Stewardship in Modern Society (Grand Rapids, Eerdmans, 1987).

Global Philanthropy Environment Index

Last month Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy released the results of their first Global Philanthropy Environment Index, which rates the enabling environment for philanthropy in 79 countries and econmonies and 11 regions around the globe. This video helps explain this work and it's importance in the world of philanthropy. 

Press Release

Girl in field

Rethinking Stewardship: From Solemn Obligation to Inspired Choice

The church is shifting from a time when people gave money out of a sense of duty and obligation. We've entered a period in which trust in institutions is low, and individuals value their power to choose. What does contextual stewardship require today? Consider this opportunity July 25-27 at Luther Seminary in St. Paul, MN for three days of conversation and exploration.

Learn More

Luther Seminary Logo

Follow Lake Institute on Twitter Like Lake Institute on Facebook

Lilly Family School of Philanthropy social media channels

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
Indiana University

Copyright © 2021 The Trustees of Indiana University

Accessibility | Privacy Notice

  • About
    • Founding of the School
    • History
    • Message from the Dean
    • International
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Partnerships
    • Annual Reports
    • Strategic Plan
    • University Hall
  • Admissions
    • How to Apply
      • B.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • M.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • Graduate Certificates
      • Ph.D. in Philanthropic Studies
    • Financial Aid & Scholarships
      • B.A. Scholarships
      • M.A. Scholarships
      • Doctoral Dissertation Fellowships
        • Women's Philanthropy Institute Doctoral Dissertation Fellowship
      • AmeriCorps Alums
    • Student Referrals
    • Plan a Visit
  • Academics
    • B.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • Winter Session Courses
      • Fall 2020 Courses
      • Capstone ePortfolio Showcase
      • Honors Program
      • Undergraduate Certificate in Philanthropic Fundraising
      • B.A. Student Profiles
      • Celebrity Philanthropy course
    • M.A. in Philanthropic Studies
      • Winter Session Courses
      • Enrollment and Placement Data
      • M.A. Program Testimonials
    • Graduate Certificates
    • Ph.D. in Philanthropic Studies
      • Doctoral Minor in Philanthropic Studies
      • Enrollment and Placement Data
      • Dissertations
      • Ph.D. students
    • Dual Degree Programs
    • Certificates & Minors
    • Accelerated B.A./M.A. Program
    • Virtual Commencement 2020
    • Internships
    • Careers
      • The Patterson Foundation Fellows Program
      • Career & Leadership Preparedness
    • Meet our Faculty
    • Philanthropic Studies Library
    • Study Abroad
    • Alumni and Student Map
  • Professional Development
    • About The Fund Raising School
      • Our Faculty
      • Alumni Stories
    • TFRS at Your Desk
    • Courses & Seminars
      • Course Locations
      • Offered by The Fund Raising School
      • Leadership Roundtable
      • How to Register
    • Customized Training
      • Fundraising for Deans
    • Certificates
      • Fund Raising Management
      • Fund Raising Leadership
      • Nonprofit Executive Leadership
      • Current Affairs Fundraising Series
      • Accreditation
    • Scholarships
      • Dottie Rosso Scholarship
      • Hank Rosso Scholarship
      • Crisis Response Scholarship
    • Mobile App
    • Webinars
      • Archive
      • Fridays with The Fund Raising School
    • Podcast
  • Research
    • COVID-19 Tracking
      • Community Foundations and United Ways
    • Current Research Projects
    • Contract Research
    • 8 Myths of Philanthropy
    • Generosity for Life
    • Global Philanthropy Indices
    • Million Dollar List
    • Partnerships
    • Faculty Research & Publications
      • Books
    • Lilly Family Faculty & Student Grants
    • Research Archive
  • Institutes
    • Lake Institute on Faith & Giving
      • COVID-19 Congregational Study
      • COVID-19 Resources
      • Courses & Seminars
        • Cultivating Generous Congregations
        • Executive Certificate in Religious Fundraising
      • Annual Programs
      • Grants & Scholarships
      • Recommended Faith & Giving Resources
      • Board of Advisors
      • Muslim Philanthropy Initiative
        • Programs
          • Community Collaboration Initiative
          • Zakat Foundation Institute Fellowship
        • Council of Advisors
        • Staff
        • News
        • Symposiums
    • Mays Family Institute on Diverse Philanthropy
      • About
      • Events
      • Resources
    • Women’s Philanthropy Institute
      • Research
      • Newest Report
      • Complete Research Library
      • Infographics & Visuals
      • Philanthropy Plugged In
      • Newsroom
        • Press Releases
        • Media Coverage
        • Writing and Musings
      • About
      • Council
  • News & Events
    • Philanthropy and COVID-19
    • News
    • Blog
    • Events
      • Perspectives on Philanthropy Discussion Series
    • Philanthropy Matters
      • 2020 Issues
      • 2019 Issues
      • 2021 Issues
    • Insights Newsletter
      • 2021 Issues
      • 2020 Issues
      • 2019 Issues
      • 2018 Issues
      • 2017 Issues
      • 2016 Issues
    • Philanthropy Research Workshop
      • Fall 2020
      • Spring 2020
  • Giving
    • Make a Gift
    • Areas to Support
    • Giving Societies
    • Class Gift
    • Donor Bill of Rights
  • Directory
  • Contact
  • Alumni
    • Alumni Board
    • Contact Info
    • Distinguished Alumni
    • Get Involved
    • Share Your Success