Questions for Reflection
- How do the results of Giving USA 2021 align with what you've seen in your own context and community over the last year?
- How can you use this data to help you move forward as an adaptive, learning organization?
by David P. King, PhD, Karen Lake Buttrey Director
In the most challenging of years, Americans persevered in their propensity to give. With the release of the annual Giving USA 2021 report published by Giving USA Foundation last week, our research colleagues within the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy found that total charitable giving increased 5.1% in 2020. What do these numbers mean for the variety of donors and nonprofits that experienced this past year quite differently? How does the story of charitable giving fit with the particular circumstances of congregations and religious nonprofits? And finally, what might these comprehensive 2020 findings tell us about the present and future of faith-based giving?
In focusing on the donor side of the giving equation, a few trends emerge. With the economic shock of the effects of COVID-19 as well as the uncertainty around markets and reopening plans, giving by corporations saw the biggest decline (-6.1%) over the last year. Yet, giving to bequests and foundations grew significantly (10.3% and 17% respectively). Many foundations responded to the pandemic by going beyond their regular grantmaking to meet the immediate needs in communities to provide food, shelter, and healthcare. Others responded to increased public advocacy sparked in the wake of George Floyd’s murder with calls for change within philanthropy to invest in Black, Indigenous, and people of color (BIPOC)-led nonprofits and their communities. Additionally, the largest foundations are being encouraged to take the crises of 2020 as momentum to contribute even more than the minimum five percent payout requirement to address the pressing issues of equity, justice, and community change.
Giving by individuals grew by 2.2%. While a relatively modest growth, this past year highlighted the growing fortunes and philanthropic investments of several mega-donors in contrast to the regular broad-based giving of other Americans. As billionaire philanthropist MacKenzie Scott illustrated through the headlines garnered through her $6 billion in donations to nonprofits in 2020 (and another $2.7 billion already in 2021), the wealth gap is growing both in society and philanthropy even as some philanthropists are seeking ways to respond.
What do these trends mean for the nonprofits that rely on charitable giving? Several of the subsectors seeing the largest growth over the past year were those on the frontlines of the economic and health crises. Giving to human services grew 9.7% while donations to public-society benefit organizations increased by 15.7%. These organizations faced increased needs last year. They served as the frontline agencies responding to hunger, basic needs, and social services. Agencies like United Ways, Jewish federations, and community development corporations were also well positioned as established clearinghouses able to distribute funds quickly through local networks serving communities.
Subsectors that struggled – like the arts/culture/humanities (-7.5%) and health (-3%) – may have declined because of missed fundraising opportunities dependent on in-person events. Most museums and concert halls were closed – the galas, races, and raffles that often raise major support for specific diseases or causes also did not happen or were moved online. Beyond the organizations that were responding to the specific crises of the last year, organizations with deeply committed ongoing donors and ingrained fundraising practices that could be moved online seemed to do better.
For those of us focused on religious giving trends in particular, the same patterns from previous years generally continue. Religious giving (narrowly defined as predominantly giving to congregations, denominations, missionary societies, and religious media) grew one percent this past year, but compared to the overall 5% growth across the charitable sector, religious giving continues to lose market share. While still the largest subsector at 28% of total giving, the overall percentage has continued to decline rather drastically over the past few decades.
Yet, considering the circumstances in such a unique year, if you predicted religious giving would remain basically flat, I imagine most religious leaders would be happy with those results. Alongside the shuttering of almost all in-person services for most of last year, congregations had to find new avenues for the majority of giving that occurred through these in-person services. While Payroll Protection Program (PPP) and federal government stimulus payments may have helped some people and organizations, faith-based organizations did have to adapt their methods of fundraising too. Lake Institute’s early COVID-19 Congregational Study found that 84% of congregations had the ability to accept contributions online before or right after the pandemic began.
Quick adaptation to new forms of asking for and receiving support became essential for most religious organizations, and many demonstrated remarkable resiliency in responding. At the same time, the challenges of the pandemic highlighted even greater differences between religious organizations. The contrast was not simply due to differences across size, age, or ease with technology, but also the openness of the organization to respond to change. When faced with disruption to traditional practices, some organizations met the challenge, developed new capacities, and established new habits and practices. Under a variety of stresses, other organizations did not have the capacity for creativity, resisted change, or simply hoped for the best. Often these contrasting approaches differentiated organizations that found success or faced diminished capacities over this past year.
On top of these disruptions from the pandemic, religious giving also faced ongoing challenges from declining trends in affiliation, attendance, and membership. Gallup reported that for the first time, in 2020 less than half of Americans reported membership in a congregation. If religious identity and activity are leading indicators of giving to both religion and secular causes, these trends remain concerning. Headlines focused on Christian nationalism and polarization may lead some to give out of their particular political passions, but overall, it leads many others to disassociate from engaging with traditional religious organizations. Fewer and fewer Americans identify their religious identity as significant in influencing their civic engagement. Over half of all Americans admit that neither religion nor spirituality influences their civic engagement, although spirituality remains a much more significant influence than religion. As the frameworks around giving, volunteering, and engaging our communities are changing, faith-based organizations must be ready to respond in new ways.
As we enter a new stage of the pandemic in the second half of 2021, Lake Institute recently surveyed our Insights readers to look ahead to the key challenges over the next year. Through our initial analysis of the responses received, it appears that, in contrast to last year, many organizations are embracing an openness to prioritizing future-oriented goals. If last year’s first response was simply pivoting and survival, this year, the emphasis has turned toward a capacity for strategic thinking and planning, grounded in mission and purpose, but strongly oriented toward serving needs in the community.
Yet, at the same time, those organizations with energy for strategic planning are also realistic. They are ready to focus on repurposing existing resources to produce a more streamlined and sustainable future. To be clear, this is not a resignation of religious organizations to shrink and become a smaller, weaker version of themselves, but rather seizing an opportunity to reimagine their mission in a new context.
If religious organizations may be destined for a less resource-rich environment, what is the future that we are funding? As donors and faith-based organizations contend with this challenge, the questions of money, meaning, and mission are central. Lake Institute is eager to walk along side organizations through this challenge as we face these most pressing questions in the days ahead.
by Ronnie Plasters, Lake Institute Graduate Assistant & IU Lilly Family School of Philanthropy PhD Student
When I began researching religious giving trends in preparation for writing the 2021 GUSA report for religion, the obvious question loomed: how much did the pandemic impact giving? Highlights from the Giving USA report indicate that Americans responded generously, setting a national giving record. This success, however, may overshadow two key facets with longstanding implications: First, small organizations dependent upon in-person programming and fundraising bore the brunt of negative impact. Second, these impressive fundraising results do not convey the incredible stories of the ways in which many nonprofits, especially religious Americans, met unprecedented, historic need.
Online Is Here To Stay
Digital philanthropy generated 13% of all donations in 2020, comprising a 21% increase over 2019 according to Blackbaud’s 2020 giving report. The pandemic likely accelerated this digital trend with 92% of givers now giving exclusively online. Moreover, Givelify found that an overwhelming majority of religious attendees intend to continue online giving—even as physical gatherings resume.
But, as Lake Institute’s Covid-19 Study indicates, only 54% of smaller congregations with less than 50 weekly participants currently employ online giving compared to 94% of congregations with more than 100 weekly participants. For megachurches with 2,000+ regular participants, online giving has become ubiquitous with more than half of all giving revenue for these congregations arriving digitally. Moreover, 84% of these churches offered streaming services even before the pandemic and their year over year attendance continues to increase by 75%.
Religious Communities’ Powerful Response
The pandemic may have taken center stage in 2020, but natural disasters and social injustice also played significant roles. And while some congregations made headlines as super spreaders, the majority became centers of information, resources, and action.
Latino churches in LA offered free Covid testing and in New York City, Convent Avenue Baptist in Harlem did the same for locally, underserved populations at the request of the New York governor. These and other efforts caught the attention of Stop The Spread, inspiring hundreds more partnerships. Jewish Americans launched Serve the Moment meant to reach vulnerable members of society while Muslim Americans responded to the deep freeze in Texas and the aftermath of hurricane Laura, solidifying their intentional effort to actively respond to emergency needs across the nation. At the same time, predominantly black churches stepped up, turning large swaths of church-owned land into new housing developments for the homeless, while also ensuring civic engagement via souls to polls efforts.
These two facets of 2020 giving in review cannot be overstated or undercelebrated. The pandemic has forever altered our lives, but the impact looks both hopeful and impressive, even beyond the record-setting giving. Congregations will find greater engagement and funding when leveraging digital technology, which in turn allows religious Americans to become vital players in meeting everyday needs and disaster-generated relief. From health provisions to housing and from rescue efforts to community building, 2020 has brought clear learnings with incredible impact. The difficulties endured and lessons learned serve as springboards of action—with compounding results now and into the future.
A Distinguished Visitors Dialogue featuring
Dan Cardinali and Kerry Robinson
in partnership with the Consortium of Endowed Episcopal Parishes
Wednesday, June 30, 2021
3:00 – 4:15 pm EDT
Join two remarkable nonprofit innovators as they discuss the ethical and practical strengths at the intersection of philanthropy and faith.
In a time of creative disruption and transformation, nonprofit organizations of all kinds are reevaluating their funding models and the organizational priorities that shape missional activity, in response to both external forces and internal pressures.
How can nonprofits best operate from their deepest values, and make meaning with their stakeholders? What can philanthropy contribute to the transformation taking place in the nonprofit sector? How might religious or faith-based organizations inform this work?
Drop in for conversation with Lake Institute on Faith & Giving and your fellow leaders in congregations and religious nonprofit institutions. Bring your questions and your experiences to a virtual roundtable exchange of ideas. All are welcome to each session, but topics of conversation will center around different issues of faith and giving each week. Each conversation will take place from 2-3 pm Eastern on Zoom -- you'll receive the link a day in advance. We'll start with "Engaging Different Generations in Generosity" tomorrow, June 23rd.